Before we begin
On a personal note, I absolutely love working with 2e kids. I often say, “the more complex the kid, the better”, because 2e kids are truly the most interesting people I know. They tend to be intellectually deep, super creative, emotionally intense, quirky, and when they get their educational needs met, they do really cool things as adults! Many of the people who “change the world” were 2e kids! They’re just super cool people, and too many of them fall through the cracks because they are misunderstood.
Adults don’t always understand their strengths and/or challenges, in fact, strengths and challenges often mask each other. Consequently, rather than figuring out what these kids need to thrive, they are often shamed with ignorant messages like, “you’re lazy”, “you don’t try hard enough”, “you don’t care enough about school”, “you just need to more discipline and motivation”. These shame comments don’t help, they hurt, and many of these kids internalize the messages and begin to feel like they are not enough, that they are stupid, that they are failures, or that they are broken.
I happen to see these kids as the most important game changers for creatively solving the world’s future problems, and it’s particularly important to society as a whole that these kids get the education they need. Now let’s dive in…
What is 2e or Twice Exceptional?
Twice exceptional aka 2e students are generally identified as both intellectually gifted & talented and learning disabled. In the education world, giftedness and learning disabilities are both considered “exceptionalities”, so the term “twice-exceptional” refers to a student with exceptionalities on both sides of the proverbial bell curve. In a nutshell, if you have a child who you know is smart/bright, but who struggles to show it, they may be 2e. It’s estimated that about 5% of kids are 2e.
The ‘2e’ abbreviation – People use the abbreviation “2e” for simplicity. It’s used interchangeably with the term “twice-exceptional”.
Multi-exceptional – Many professionals, myself included, prefer the term “multi-exceptional” because of how complex these kids are. Labels like 2e can be misleading because there is often a lot more that needs to be considered when planning to meet the complex educational needs of these kids. For example, it’s not uncommon to have an intellectually gifted child who has also been diagnosed with adhd, asd, processing disorders, and an emotional disorder. Unfortunately, teachers rarely know the full story, and even if they do, they are not always given the time, training or resources they need in order to meet the needs of these kids.
Asynchrony – The #1 key concept to help understand 2e learners is asynchrony, aka dyssynchrony. 2E kids tend to develop quite “asynchronously”. They are “all over the place” in terms of grade level ability or age appropriate development. For example, you might have a 6th grader who reads at the 12th grade level, has the fine-motor handwriting of a 1st grader, writes papers like a 3rd grader, understands math concepts at an 9th grade level, calculates math facts at a 4th grade level, can hold remarkably deep conversations with adults, and has temper tantrums like a 3 year old. You get the picture, the developmental levels of 2e kids aren’t “in sync”. The discrepancies between “potential” and “output” causes many problems.
I like to think of asynchrony like an old stereo EQ (see below). Imagine that each slider represents one developmental area. Perhaps one slider represents math, writing, reading, social, emotional, visual spatial (of course you could break it down into smaller sub-skills if you wanted to). Sliding it up indicates greater ability and down indicates less ability as compared to most peers of a similar age. The image below could describe someone who was “on grade level” since the different domains are all at the same level, they are in sync. Standardized tests for such a child would show average grade level scores (they might be labeled “proficient” on tests). Now imagine an eq for a 2e child where the sliders were all over the place, some average, some very high, some very low. This would represent asynchronous development.
Neuro-typical – When discussing 2e kids, it’s good to be familiar with the term “neurotypical” (a word commonly used in ASD circles, originally used to refer to non-ASD people). This word refers to kids who experience “neurologically typical” development cognitively, socially, emotionally. For example, it might be considered neurotypical to learn multiplication tables in 3rd grade or to be able to write a good research paper by high school. Some would argue that neurotypicals compose the 80% of kids in the “middle” of the bell curve. 2eF kids are, of course, by their very nature, not neurotypical.
Bell curve – Bell curves can be useful when used properly, but the metaphor of the bell curve can cause a lot of misunderstanding. I want to clarify how I think of it so you can have a better understanding to help your kids. The bell curve below is called the “normal bell curve” and the world normal carries a lot of baggage. The problem is that if there are “normal” people than there are “abnormal” people, and that frame can carry a lot of hurtful judgement. I have seen way too many kids who feel like they are broken, who feel like there is something wrong with them, and those feelings can cause a lot of trauma. I wanted to mention this because it’s important that we are careful about the messages we send.
3-d Bell Curve
I think of the normal bell curve as being limited and one-dimensional. In other words, it doesn’t give me nearly enough information about the complexities that make up students. These are human beings with incredibly complex and rich personalities and learning needs. Therefore, I like to think of these metrics as parts of 3-d bells, with countless interrelated qualities . Imagine that you could look at this bell from hundreds of angles to get perspective on various relevant aspects of these kids. It’s so much more interesting and useful.
Identification: How do I know if my child is 2E or Twice Exceptional?
It’s critical for parents and teachers to have clarity regarding their Twice Exceptional students, because a failure to understand them can have devastating effects. Also, as stated above, adults who don’t understand 2e often use shaming words that are damaging, sending misinformed messages that these kids are lazy, don’t care about school or don’t try hard enough.
Testing for intelligence and learning disabilities – 2e students are “smart but struggling”, so if this describes your child, you should explore this until you feel clear about what’s going on. Generally parents have a gut feeling about this sort of thing, but many families find clarity through getting professional testing done by a neuropsychologist or other diagnostician who tests for giftedness and learning problems. Schools may also provide testing in order to see if they will offer services.
When parents ask me to refer to someone for testing, the most important factor I consider is how well the diagnostician consults with a family after testing. For example, my favorite neuoropsychologist in Colorado spends a great deal of time with families afterwards so they leave with all of their questions thoroughly answered. I’ve seen too many families come to me with an overwhelming 10-page report that they don’t even know how to read. What good is paying for testing when you don’t understand the results?
Common tests – WISC IV, WAIS III, Stanford Binet, Woodcock-Johnson, DAS, UNIT, Ravens Progressive Matrices, NNAT, K-TEA/NU.
Discrepancies – The difference between what a child should be able to do and their actual execution causes a great deal of problems for these kids. Adults often say things like, “he’s got so much potential, I don’t know why he doesn’t try harder?!?!”. These kids are trying, but it’s often masked. These kids are working very hard using their strengths and intelligence to compensate for their weaknesses, so they are often misunderstood. Unfortunately, the opposite is often true, their challenges can mask their gifts.
Common Learning Disabilities, Differences or Challenges
Don’t let the stigma of the word “disabled” (dis-able) scare you, because what’s most important is that you know the truth about your child’s abilities and needs. Even when there is no formal diagnosis, parents often have an intuition about their child’s “gifts” and “disabilities.” Here are some common differences to look out for:
- Dysgraphia – writing disability
- Dyscalculia – math disability
- Processing disorders (sensory – visual, auditory)
- ASD, Aspergers, Autism
- Dyspraxia, Sensory integration, fine motor problems
- Dysphasia – problems understanding language
- Speech & language
- ADHD, attentional, executive function
- TBI Traumatic Brain Injury
- Emotional disorders, depression, bipolar, anxiety, OCD, etc.
Types of Gifts to consider
It does not have to be “book smarts,” there are many ways a child can be gifted:
- IQ, GT is often thought of as 130+, 160+ is often considered profoundly gifted
- Academically – math, science, language arts, etc.
- Artistically – art, music, dance, etc.
- Kinesthetically, Athletically
- Verbal ability
- Visual spatial
- Problem solving ability, original, unique ideas
- Abstract thinking, flexible thinking, highly creative, insightful
- Gardner’s Multiple Intelligences: musical, interpersonal, intrapersonal, logical-mathematical, linguistic, naturalistic, visual-spatial, bodily/kinesthetic
- Asks unusually deep questions, High level thinking
- Intuitive or spiritual, “indigo kids”
- Unusually observant in strength areas, learns very quickly in strength areas
- Can communicate in a very mature way (sometimes being incredibly immature at other times)
- Enjoys intellectual challenge
- Advanced sense of humor
- Remembers a lot of details easily
- Crave learning and intellectual stimulation
What are the common challenges facing 2e learners
Here’a a list of common problems these leaners face. It is by no means a comprehensive list, but should adequately shed some light on the issue.
- They fall through the cracks, don’t get their needs met, waste years of their adult lives “finding themselves”
- People who don’t understand 2E learners often use ignorant statements like this: “He’s just being lazy”, “She’s not trying her best”, “He doesn’t care enough about school”, “What a shame, she’s got so much potential”.
- Compensatory strategies that these kids use can mask the gifts or the legitimate learning differences/disabilities (“masking” can even lead to NOT being diagnosed)
- Discrepancies between strengths and challenge areas can negatively affect how these kids are perceived
- Low grades can mask true ability
- Schools don’t keep up with the research on 2e and don’t train teachers adequately to serve them
- These kids are often bored, they learn fast and when a school doesn’t accelerate curriculum, these kids disengage
- They can be sick of things that feel like pointless busywork and refuse to do homework
- They often thrive with different aged peers but are kept with same-age peers because of “grade level”
- Can’t take advanced class because they are “underachieving”, causing more boredom and resistance
- Pull out programs may not be adequate
- Pullouts may make them feel different since they are being pulled out of class (middle schoolers hate to look different)
- Sometimes kids in pullout programs still have to make up “missed” work
- Sometimes there are no accommodations whatsoever, often when there has been no identification or while they are going through an RTI process that drags out
- Never tested at all
- Overexcitabilities, sensory, emotional (see Dabrowski)
- Have to “do what everyone else does” even though it isn’t working for them
- Deficits can shadow gifts: often, there is a lot of emphasis on how they are NOT performing, they can’t shine,
- Diagnosis – as you can imagine, these kids can be difficult to diagnose. When kids take tests, many factors can influence the results in both directions, including processing, compensation, intuition. Under-diagnosis, over-diagnosis, misdiagnosis, no diagnosis
- They can learn to resent school and learning particularly after middle school begins.
- May not “look” gifted
- Standardized test problems
- The can internalize shame and feel bad about themselves
- They don’t know the value of their strengths
- They don’t develop gifts/talents/strengths
- They don’t feel capable
- Don’t know how to advocate for themselves, how to articulate what they need
How to support and empower 2e learners
- Use education (and life experiences) to build upon their strengths, gifts, talents, interests, passions
- Don’t put too much emphasis working on weaknesses. There’s a time and a place to do this, but it should be done mindfully.
- Create project based lessons based on interests, that give students ownership and choice in their learning
- Use experiential learning experiences
- Use authentic forms of assessment
- Get rid of assessments that do not measure what we are looking for
- Get rid of pointless busywork
- Rethink homework altogether and only give homework when there is a real purpose
- Understand what the research says about the value of homework (hint: it’s not nearly as valuable as you might think and interferes with much needed family, social and play time)
- Alternate product possibilities based on student choice, don’t just do tests and papers for assessment
- Provide alternate options for how kids process knowledge
- Support social and emotional needs
- Coach EF skills, like how to chunk studying, how to use a planner, organize, etc..
- Teach HOW to learn, not just what to learn
- Build independence
- Differentiate: Scaffold the curriculum. Accelerate curriculum to keep pace with learning. Compress curriculum,
- Teach self care
- Catch em’ being good, celebrate even small successes
- Provide kids with great role models, older peers who can guide them
- Make sure that documented accommodations actually work! They should be carefully and thoughtfully articulated so they effectively communicate to teachers what is needed. I cannot tell you how many times I’ve seen accommodations that are unclear and thus meaningless. Also, the older kids get, the less their teachers know about their accommodations, so advocacy is critical.
- Expose them to a diverse range of experiences to expose them to many areas where passions may develop
- Plan experiences that allow them to explore their curiosities
- Allow them to use their imaginations regularly to explore learning
- Dynamic assessment, performance assessment
- Ideas for teachers and parents they can post
- Use adequate wait time. Be patient and let them process their thoughts instead of expecting quick responses.
- Give honest compliments and praise… Often.
- Actively listen to your children: Ask “what do you think? Why, why, why?” Really listen.
- Design creatively differentiated curriculum
- Interdisciplinary learning experiences teaching holistic approaches
- Make learning RELEVANT, meaningful, make it matter matter, give them experiences they care about.
- Make clear expectations, in writing so it’s concrete and not abstract.
- Learn to coregulate emotionally
- Challenging work
- Don’t focus too much on memorizing facts, worry about teaching how to think
- Reconsider what “achievement” means
- Educating teachers and parents about 2e
- Advocacy, stick up for these kids (and all kids of course)
- Do your own deep, inner work. The more you take care of you, the more you can support your child
- Know your legal rights, make sure your child is properly identified and that they have effective documentation to support their needs. This may include ALPs ILPs IEPs RTI 504 Documentation (see IDEA)
Another giant issue to consider is avoidance, and it deserves it’s own section here. It’s can be very difficult to help children when they seem unmotivated, when they avoid, when they are overwhelmed, stressed, anxious, withdrawn, push you away, and when they resist help. Their emotional overwhelm is so great that they have created many tools designed to avoid the perceived stress of dealing with these issues.
Be sensitive to these issues and consider a good coach or therapist to help deal with the underlying emotions so your child can learn to break through this avoidance and start to have more successes.
As you might have guessed, 2e kids often struggle with Executive Function. Often times, because they have trouble with “execution”, their grades do not reflect their abilities. Problems with EF/execution include problems with organization, time management, planning, prioritizing, focus, reflective thinking, emotional regulation, and more.
When giftedness is noticed and learning differences are not, adults often blame problems on laziness, not trying, low self-esteem, unmotivated rather than noticing how disability affects the learner.
When the disability is acknowledged without noticing the giftedness, adults tend to focus on weaknesses rather than strengths.
When unidentified, this is the grey area. Perhaps worst scenario of all, the most misunderstood of the 2e kids, they compensate “too well”, and the “two exceptionalities” hide one another.
Ideally, there is clarity regarding gifts and challenges so that we may design learning experiences that are appropriately challenging and supportive. Our educational culture is usually looking for easy ways to teach and measure, but kids are complex, and 2e kids are extraordinarily complex. We simply cannot rely on cookie cutter curriculum to meet the diverse needs of these learners. There is no quick fix or magic bullet. Educating these kids requires a real investment in time and energy to creating engaging and meaningful learning experiences.
Freebie: 2E Asynchrony Profile Assessment (informal)
You can download and print the the 2e.ASSESSMENT.tool here. It will help you gain a better understanding your child.
Great Links to 2e & Twice-Exceptional Resources
- 2enewsletter is a great website/blog with tons of excellent free articles. It’s probably the best resource out there and I definitely recommend subscribing.
- SENG Supporting Emotional Needs of the Gifted – a classic site got GT families
- Hoagies Gifted Site is one of the best sites out there about gifted learners. It’s a classic.
- Bridges Academy is a well-known 2e school in Studio City, CA.
- Gifted Homeschoolers is a great site for homeschool families and they have an excellent 2e resource.
- The National Center for Learning Disabilities is the place to go to understand your rights as a parent of a 2e child.
- The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) is a law ensuring educational services to children with disabilities. IDEA is good for parents and teachers to become familiar with.
Please share what 2e means to YOU! Thanks, Seth
If you liked this, please *share* now so others may be helped. Thanks!